Meloni and Trump: From an alliance of necessity to a clash of interests
Despite their previous rapprochement, a clash was expected between the US president and the Italian prime minister, who is seeking to boost her electoral prospects. For years, Italy’s right-wing Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni exploited the idea that she was the ideal European ally for US President Donald Trump and that she was capable of playing the role of mediator in his relations with the European Union. However, Rome had no chance of avoiding the blacklist of the “Make America Great Again” or “MAGA” movement. While Meloni agreed with Trump on issues such as immigration and the culture war, the MAGA movement was expected to criticize Italy’s low defense spending and its large trade surplus with the United States, according to Politico. Daniele Albertazzi, a professor at the University of Surrey, says: "Given the fundamental conflict between American and European interests, a clash was always to be expected." Although a confrontation was inevitable, it was uncertain how Meloni would respond. Unlike most world leaders who ignored Trump's personal insults, the Italian prime minister, known for her sharp stances, took the unusual step of escalating the dispute, strongly attacking the US president for violating Italy's national dignity. After Trump mocked Meloni last Friday, saying she "begged" him for a photo during the G7 summit and accusing her of exploiting their relationship for domestic political gain, she responded by saying he fabricated the incident and that her popularity is declining because of her friendship with him. The intensity of her response was carefully calculated politically in a country that deeply dislikes Trump, and at a time when Meloni is preparing for next year's elections, where an Ipsos poll in May showed that 77% of Italians have a negative view of the US president. Believing in the strong political logic of confronting Trump, Meloni received support from her partners in the ruling coalition. Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani described the US president's statements as "dangerous and offensive" and canceled a planned visit to the United States. But this does not mean that Meloni is immune to criticism. The opposition Democratic Party (center-left) stated that she was wrong to think that she could tame Trump. Meloni had strengthened her ties with Trump after his re-election, presenting herself as a link between Washington and Brussels, but the Iran war changed this course. Italian voters have expressed concern about rising energy prices and the risk of the conflict widening, making Meloni's perceived closeness to Trump a "significant liability," according to Albertazzi. Trump's attack began after Meloni started distancing herself from Washington, refusing to allow American bombers access to Italian bases. From the perspective of Trump supporters, the problems run deeper than just Italy's trade surplus. Ben Harnowell, the international editor of Steve Bannon's television program "War Room," said the White House was increasingly annoyed by Meloni's efforts to present herself as a mediator between Washington and Europe. He added: "Trump doesn't need an intermediary... He can make a phone call to anyone of importance, without needing Meloni's help." He claimed that Trump's public attack was intended to send a message, saying: "By speaking to an Italian network, Trump clearly wanted to humiliate it in front of its own people." Albertazzi considered the attack too insulting to ignore and said: "She had to respond, because I think the political price of not responding would have been too high." He added: "Trump treated her superficially, like a fan... and as a nationalist, she needs to maintain the image of someone with dignity and strength." However, Harnowell cautioned against interpreting the disagreement as a permanent break, saying, "Trump doesn't hold a grudge... You can disagree with him and then come back to him as long as you acknowledge that he has the final say," noting that Italy's importance within the White House should not be exaggerated. Despite Meloni's potential electoral gains from her sharp disagreement with Trump, Rome shows no real indication of abandoning its broader strategic alliance with Washington. While Tajani cancelled his trip to Washington, he insisted on attending the 250th anniversary celebrations of the founding of the United States on July 4 in Rome, celebrations of great importance to Trump. Claudio Borghi, a senator from the far-right League party, said Rome should have embraced Trump's goals for Europe more closely from the outset, including pursuing bilateral tariff negotiations with Washington instead of working through Brussels, and advised the government to "do everything possible from today to overcome this unfortunate situation diplomatically." Political scientist and associate dean of the Rome Business School, Leo Gorti, said that Italy, despite public rhetoric, still relies on the transatlantic alliance as much as it always has. He added that "Melloni's initial firm response does not affect Italy's policy, which is still trying to maintain the transatlantic relationship."
0 Comments