A prestigious French prize excludes a novel after its author is accused of using artificial intelligence.
The Goncourt Academy, France’s most prestigious literary prize, has taken a surprising step, excluding Thielsson Aurélien’s bestselling novel from its longlist. The prize, often referred to as the French version of the Booker Prize, is considered by some to be the French equivalent of the Booker Prize. The judges say the novel was "most likely" written by artificial intelligence to a large extent, a claim the Haitian-Canadian author strongly denies. The novel, titled "C'etait Ca ou Mourir" (It Was Either That or Death), tells the story of a man fleeing gang violence in Haiti on a long journey to Canada. The novel has already won several awards and was awaiting translation, according to reports seen by Al Arabiya Business. However, an anonymous account on the X platform, named Balance ton Claude, accused Aurélien a few days ago of using artificial intelligence. The account analyzed excerpts from the novel using Pangram, an AI detection tool currently used by Substack to vet publications, and classified the novel as almost entirely machine-written. Article writer Samuel Fitoussi later admitted to being part of the group behind the "X" account. Reports then surfaced alleging that Aurélien had plagiarized passages in a 2012 short story by French author Louis Paël. The Goncourt Academy said it took this step to protect the integrity of the prize by rejecting texts created with the help of artificial intelligence. It cited allegations of AI use and plagiarism as the basis for its decision. But Aurélien insists he could rewrite the same book using a pen. The case has sparked a debate in France about race, literary merit, and originality. The controversy quickly spread beyond a single book, echoing the allegations of artificial intelligence misuse that rocked the Commonwealth Short Story Prize earlier this year. The case also raises questions about whether AI detection tools should influence decisions that could affect an author's career. The Authors Guild of America warns that some AI-generated content detection tools are highly inaccurate and should never be the sole reason for withdrawing a book. Ironically, most readers tend to rate AI-generated stories higher, yet they still place more trust in the label of "human creation."
0 Comments